Showing posts with label JP Morgan chase. Show all posts
Showing posts with label JP Morgan chase. Show all posts

Monday, May 13, 2013

Great Men + Weak Governance = Bad Decisions


The on-going JP Morgan Chase, London Whale drama about striping Jamie Dimon of his joint CEO-Board Chairman title, along with the replacement of some directors, raises interesting governance lessons. These lessons are not just limited to JP, Dimon and banking. They apply to most major decisions, good and bad, including M&A.

Dimon is a strong willed, successful, confident leader, some would say over confidant, AKA a great man. He runs a large complex organization operating in a challenging industry undergoing rapid change. As the Whale incident demonstrates, he operates with limited board oversight. JP’s board is large, has a long tenure, and was handpicked by Dimon, who controls the selection and nominating process.  The board has limited industry technical experience in key areas like risk management. Hence, it is deferential to the CEO/Chairman’s wishes and decisions. This is reinforced by his relatively successful navigation of his bank thru the financial crisis.

As Douglas Hubband notes, never attribute to malice or stupidity that which can be explained by moderately rational individuals following incentives in a complex system of interactions. The purpose of board governance is to protect the institution from being driven by the narrow interest of an individual, the great man. Absent this governance check, Warren Buffett’s Institutional Imperative takes hold.

Institutional Imperative involves (1) resisting change, (2) staff support of leadership desires and actions regardless of merit using all means available including complex financial models and detailed strategic plans prepared by expensive and high profile advisors and (3) slavishly following peer behavior. It is very difficult to challenge great men decisions and desires. This is probably best summed up by former MGM head Louis B. Mayer’s comment that “….he admired men who were unafraid to speak their mind even if it cost them their jobs.”

Some possible control mechanisms include:
1)     Spliting the CEO and Board Chairman roles
2)     Obtaining a strong lead director capable of challenging the great man
3)     Smaller boards
4)     Independent experienced directors - no more museum directors on the bank board!
5)     Proper incentives for both management and the board

Perhaps most importantly, a culture which encourages professional challenge of senior management decisions is needed. JP’s management discussion in their 2012 annual report in which they discuss the London Whale problem provides some interesting points - albeit learned the hard way after a $6B loss.  Some of the more important points are as follows:

1)     Fight complacency: do not assume tomorrow will look like today. Question others and let others question you-especially after a long period of when thing have gone well.
2)     Overcome conflict avoidance: ask hard questions.
3)     Controls must match the activity being conducted. This means for big ‘bet your company type’, major acquisitions use a rigorous independent review process.
4)     Trust but verify: the board should not micro manage executives. Neither, should it blindly assume they are correct. Make them verify their plans.
5)     Do not shoot the messenger: encourage everyone to quickly surface problems so they can be fixed before they become fatal.

Even great men have bad days and make bad decisions. Good governance can help minimize the damages of those bad decisions on their organizations.

J

Monday, April 22, 2013

Listening to Shareholders Can Be Hard to Do


Firms compete in two primary markets. The first being in product markets for customers and the second in capital markets for capital. Shareholder activism increases when stock prices fall based on declining product market performance. The stock price decline reflects a value gap between a firm’s current business model and a higher alternative value strategy. This becomes most pronounced during periods of rapid industry changes, a creative destruction, due to technology, regulation and deflation. Currently, the industries with the greatest change and activism are energy (e.g. Hess), tech (e.g. Dell) and banking (e.g. JP Morgan Chase).

Activism is an external mechanism along with hostile takeovers to prod slow changing firms. It usually reflects weak corporate governance. A substantial value gap, usually greater than 30%, is needed to incent a financial activist like Carl Icahn and others to risk their capital. It is frequently a last step before a more serious product market failure like that which occurred at Eastman Kodak.

Understandably, management and their supporters dislike being told they need to change. This attitude was perhaps best expressed by the early 20th century German banker Carl Fuerstenberg who stated:

                  Shareholders are stupid and impertinent-stupid because they gave their money to somebody else without any effective control and impertinent because they ask for a dividend as a reward for their stupidity.

Typically, management alleges the industry changes are cyclical not structural and that consequently, shareholders should be patient. Activist, are frequently attacked as short –term in nature and unable to see the true long term value of the firm they are questioning. This attack is based on the short holding period of the activists as shareholders. Nonetheless, value is based on the market’s investment horizon, not the holding period of a firm’s shareholders. Thus, the key issue is-are firms targeted by activists under-valued, as management believes, or under- managed as the activists contend?

Eventually, change affects all companies-even formerly successful market leaders. As Schumpeter taught us-we are only king for a day. Just look at the turnover in the S&P 500 during the first 12 years of the 21st Century. Over a third of the firms have been replaced through decline, failure or merger. Examples include Texaco, Sears, Circuit City, and Quaker among others. Andy Grove was right-in such a rapidly changing environment only the paranoid survive.

No one likes being questioned. Sometimes, that is exactly what is needed before it becomes too late to change. So, listen to those “stupid and impertinent” shareholders. They may just have something to say that is worth hearing.

Joe