Showing posts with label Projections. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Projections. Show all posts

Monday, February 17, 2014

Synergies: Dreams or Nightmares?

Synergies can become one of the four big lies along with “the check is in the mail”. Theoretically, they are just an expression of the extra value a buyer can achieve from an acquisition target. They are key to offsetting the premium paid to make the transaction work from the buyer’s point of view. Unfortunately, they can be easily abused to justify over priced acquisitions. In essence they can become the “plug” to legitimize any transaction. As Warren Buffett notes “although many deals fail in practice-none fail in spreadsheets”.  I use the following tests when evaluating synergies:

1)     Premium: a premium exceeding 40% of the pre bid target price is an indicator of the need for inflated synergies to make the deal work-at least on paper.

2)     Projection Inputs: every valuation and its underlying projections are based on six variables which should be compared against the base rate-historical results and peers. The key variable are:
a)     Revenue Growth: revenue synergies are especially suspect. Competitors have a nasty habit of quickly responding to attempted market share gains.
b)     Operating Profit Margin Increases: cost synergies are more believable than revenue growth. Nonetheless, integration expenses and other unplanned items must be considered. Also, competitors may crimp gross margins through decreased prices.
c)     Taxes: lower tax rate assumptions should be questioned.
d)     CAPEX: growth requires supporting investment infrastructure.
e)     Working Capital Increases: additional inventory and receivables from growth should be expected.
f)      Weighted Average Cost of Capital (WACC): beware of financial engineering and other sleights of hand. You should discount the targets cash flows at its unlevered cost of equity relevered for its new target capital structure-not at the acquirer’s WACC, which is usually lower.

3)     Reality Checks
a)     Value the Projections: if the value based on believable inputs substantially exceeds the price, then ask why the acquirer is so lucky to receive this generosity. The M&A market is relatively efficient. Hence bargains are rare.
b)     Compensation: tie the projections into the compensation of the deal’s proponents. They should be at risk just like the acquirer’s shareholders.
c)     Covenants: bank loan covenants tied to the projections for items including leverage and fixed charge ratios may give management reason to reconsider its projections.
d)     Consistency: due diligence and integration plans should support and be consistent with the synergy projections.

As President Reagan noted- trust, but verify. The same goes for synergies.


J

Thursday, April 18, 2013

Corporate Governance, Acquisitions and the Interdisciplinary Connections of Business


Corporate Governance and Acquisitions are two distinct topics that cut across countless other topics - and certainly each other.   Acquisitions, for example, encompass so many different aspects of business.  First and foremost is finance.  We need finance to understand our financial projections, to make sure that the net present values are realistic and that the terminal growth and other assumptions are appropriate.  But that present value model of finance is derived from estimates of every other area of business.  Cash flow projections initially depend on sales projections from marketing.  Logistics are part of the marketing estimates as well.  If projections start with sales, they travel through accounting regulations on their way to cash flow.  Information systems are crucial avenue for decision making before, during and after acquisition.  Legal restrictions (regulatory and deal specific) permeate acquisitions.  Behavioral finance and the decision sciences are crucial for informed and unbiased decisions.

Last - and unfortunately often considered least - is the fact that all projections, all synergies, and ultimately all results,  are driven by people.  Numbers are essential, but without the proper personnel they are meaningless.  A business and hence its cash flow, work only through people.  It is true for the goods and services a firm delivers and it is true for the decisions executives make.  Numbers don't make decisions.  People make decisions.

Which brings us to Corporate Governance.  Corporate Governance involves the alignment of owners and managers and like acquisitions impacts (and is impacted by) virtually every area of a business.  It is certainly true that many deals are driven by an opportunity to increase value through better governance.  In private equity, for example, a firm may be taken private to better align incentives for owner-managers.  In other cases, internal governance structures have failed to maximize value - external governance mechanisms (like acquisitions) rush in to fill the vacuum.  

In (a) separate post(s), I'll write about two of Drexel's premier events held recently in Central Philadelphia.  The first is our 6th Annual Academic Conference on Corporate Governance.  The second is our 5th Annual Director's Dialogue, a program on governance by and for practitioners.

All the best,

Ralph